parallel randomized trial
NCT01191268
The Impact of LY2189265 Versus Insulin Glargine in Combination With Insulin Lispro for the Treatment to Target of Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus (AWARD-4: Assessment of Weekly AdministRation of LY2189265 in Diabetes - 4)
Design
Conduct and analysis
Arms
| Arm | Treatment | Background | Randomized | Analyzed | Completed treatment |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | Dulaglutide 1.5 mg subcutaneous once weekly Dulaglutide 1.5 mg plus lispro | insulin lispro TID titrated, with or without metformin; lifestyle: not reported | 295 | 295 | |
| A2 | Dulaglutide 0.75 mg subcutaneous once weekly Dulaglutide 0.75 mg plus lispro | insulin lispro TID titrated, with or without metformin; lifestyle: not reported | 293 | 293 | |
| A3 | Insulin glargine Insulin glargine plus lispro | insulin lispro TID titrated, with or without metformin; lifestyle: not reported | 296 | 296 |
Baseline characteristics
As printed in the trial reports or registry, per arm or for the whole trial.
| Characteristic | Statistic | Dulaglutide 1.5 mg subcutaneous once weekly A1 | Dulaglutide 0.75 mg subcutaneous once weekly A2 | Insulin glargine A3 | Whole trial ALL |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| age: >=65 | n | 90 | |||
| age | mean (years) | 58.88 | 59.31 | 59.9 | |
| age | sd (years) | 9.55 | 8.98 | 9.08 | |
| asian | n | 9 | 12 | 14 | |
| black | n | 32 | 27 | 26 | |
| bmi | mean (kg/m2) | 31.99 | 33.08 | 32.41 | |
| bmi | sd (kg/m2) | 5.11 | 5.15 | 5.33 | |
| diabetes duration: >=10 | n | 199 | |||
| diabetes duration | mean (years) | 12.80 | 12.43 | 12.96 | |
| diabetes duration | sd (years) | 7.19 | 6.92 | 6.80 | |
| egfr: <60 | n | 93 | |||
| egfr: <60 | percent | 10.5 | |||
| female | n | 135 | 145 | 131 | |
| hba1c: >9 | n | 92 | |||
| hba1c | mean (percent) | 8.46 | 8.40 | 8.53 | |
| hba1c | sd (percent) | 1.08 | 1.03 | 1.03 | |
| hispanic | n | 102 | 101 | 100 | |
| insulin dose | mean (U/day) | 55.20 | 59.11 | 53.93 | |
| other race american indian alaska native | n | 16 | 13 | 17 | |
| other race multiple | n | 7 | 6 | 7 | |
| other race native hawaiian pacific islander | n | 0 | 0 | 1 | |
| sbp | mean (mmHg) | 133.26 | 134.03 | 133.26 | |
| sbp | sd (mmHg) | 16.56 | 15.87 | 16.97 | |
| uacr: >300 | n | 52 | |||
| uacr: >300 | percent | 5.9 | |||
| weight | mean (kg) | 91.00 | 91.69 | 90.75 | |
| weight | sd (kg) | 18.24 | 18.03 | 18.87 | |
| white | n | 231 | 235 | 231 |
Analyses this trial contributes to
- HbA1c changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); network meta-analysis
- HbA1c changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); pairwise meta-analysis
- HbA1c changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); network meta-analysis
- HbA1c changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); pairwise meta-analysis
- Body weight change in kilograms (diabetes)Type 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); descriptive only
- Body weight change in kilograms (diabetes)Type 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); descriptive only
- Body weight change in kilograms (diabetes)Type 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); descriptive only
- Body weight change in kilograms (diabetes)Type 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); descriptive only
- Level 2 or 3 hypoglycemia (participants)Type 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- Level 2 or 3 hypoglycemia (participants)Type 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- Systolic blood pressure changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); network meta-analysis
- Systolic blood pressure changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); network meta-analysis
- Systolic blood pressure changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 20 to 36 (target week 26); network meta-analysis
- Systolic blood pressure changeType 2 diabetes (adults); weeks 36 to 64 (target week 52); network meta-analysis
- Serious adverse eventsType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- Serious adverse eventsType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- NauseaType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- NauseaType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- VomitingType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- VomitingType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- DiarrheaType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- DiarrheaType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- ConstipationType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- ConstipationType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- Acute pancreatitisType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
- Acute pancreatitisType 2 diabetes (adults); longest follow-up; network meta-analysis
Results
110 adjudicated result lines, grouped by outcome. Open an outcome to see its values.
HbA1c change (10 lines; O01)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 vs A3 | md | -0.22 percent | -0.38 to -0.07 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A1 | change | -1.64 percent | 0.07 | 273 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 | change | -1.59 percent | 0.07 | 275 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 vs A3 | md | -0.17 percent | -0.33 to -0.02 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A3 | change | -1.41 percent | 0.07 | 276 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 | change | -1.48 percent | 0.08 | 273 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 vs A3 | md | -0.25 percent | -0.42 to -0.07 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A2 | change | -1.42 percent | 0.08 | 275 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A2 vs A3 | md | -0.19 percent | -0.37 to -0.02 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A3 | change | -1.23 percent | 0.08 | 276 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
Body weight change in kilograms (diabetes) (31 lines; O02)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 vs A3 | md | -3.20 kg | -3.81 to -2.59 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A1 | change | -0.87 kg | 0.27 | 286 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 | change | 0.18 kg | 0.27 | 289 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 vs A3 | md | -2.15 kg | -2.76 to -1.54 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A3 | change | 2.33 kg | 0.27 | 294 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26.07 | A1 | change | -0.33 kg | -0.98 to 0.33 | not stated; modified itt; sex:male; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | -1.63 kg | -2.37 to -0.88 | not stated; modified itt; sex:female; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | 0.31 kg | -0.57 to 1.19 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=5_<10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | 0.06 kg | -0.64 to 0.76 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:>=8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | -1.71 kg | -2.39 to -1.04 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:<8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | -1.64 kg | -3.04 to -0.24 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:<5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A1 | change | -0.96 kg | -1.55 to -0.38 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | 0.95 kg | 0.24 to 1.67 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:>=8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | 0.21 kg | -1.09 to 1.51 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:<5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | 0.54 kg | -0.04 to 1.13 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | 0.08 kg | -0.84 to 1.00 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=5_<10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | -0.46 kg | -1.10 to 0.19 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:<8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | -0.33 kg | -1.04 to 0.37 | not stated; modified itt; sex:female; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A2 | change | 0.61 kg | -0.07 to 1.28 | not stated; modified itt; sex:male; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 2.66 kg | 2.09 to 3.23 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 2.19 kg | 1.25 to 3.12 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:>=5_<10; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 1.70 kg | 1.03 to 2.38 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:<8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 2.96 kg | 2.28 to 3.63 | not stated; modified itt; hba1c:>=8.5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 1.98 kg | 0.58 to 3.38 | not stated; modified itt; diabetes_duration:<5; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 2.20 kg | 1.47 to 2.93 | not stated; modified itt; sex:female; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 26.07 | A3 | change | 2.34 kg | 1.69 to 3.00 | not stated; modified itt; sex:male; R0014882:Table 2 | ||
| 52 | A1 | change | -0.35 kg | 0.34 | 286 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 vs A3 | md | -3.23 kg | -3.99 to -2.48 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A2 vs A3 | md | -2.03 kg | -2.78 to -1.27 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A2 | change | 0.86 kg | 0.33 | 289 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A3 | change | 2.89 kg | 0.33 | 294 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
HbA1c below 7 percent (6 lines; O03)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 | responders | 67.6 | 275 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A2 | responders | 69.0 | 277 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 26 | A3 | responders | 56.8 | 280 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A1 | responders | 58.5 | 275 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A2 | responders | 56.3 | 277 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | ||
| 52 | A3 | responders | 49.3 | 280 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
Level 2 or 3 hypoglycemia (participants) (6 lines; O04)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 4 / 295 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A1 | events | 8 / 295 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A2 | events | 5 / 293 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A2 | events | 7 / 293 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A3 | events | 14 / 296 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A3 | events | 9 / 296 | hypothetical; safety; registry:outcomes |
Systolic blood pressure change (6 lines; O05)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 | change | -0.97 mmHg | 0.88 | 255 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 | change | -0.65 mmHg | 0.87 | 261 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A3 | change | 2.23 mmHg | 0.88 | 258 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 | change | -0.26 mmHg | 0.94 | 239 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A2 | change | 1.04 mmHg | 0.93 | 240 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A3 | change | 1.98 mmHg | 0.92 | 246 | not stated; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
All cause mortality (3 lines; O20)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 0 / 295 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow | ||||
| A2 | events | 1 / 293 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow | ||||
| A3 | events | 3 / 296 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow |
Physical functioning (any instrument) (6 lines; O24B)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 | change | -0.50 points | 0.30 | 274 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 | change | -0.60 points | 0.31 | 270 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A3 | change | -0.93 points | 0.31 | 270 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 | change | -0.50 points | 0.33 | 277 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A2 | change | -1.05 points | 0.33 | 275 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A3 | change | -1.28 points | 0.33 | 279 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
Health related quality of life total score (any instrument) (6 lines; O24C)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | A1 | change | -0.03 points | 0.01 | 272 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A2 | change | -0.03 points | 0.01 | 271 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 26 | A3 | change | -0.03 points | 0.01 | 274 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A1 | change | -0.04 points | 0.01 | 274 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A2 | change | -0.04 points | 0.01 | 274 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes | |
| 52 | A3 | change | -0.03 points | 0.01 | 281 | hypothetical; modified itt; registry:outcomes |
Serious adverse events (3 lines; O25)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 27 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 46 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 53 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events |
Discontinuation due to adverse events (3 lines; O26)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 21 / 295 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow | ||||
| A2 | events | 13 / 293 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow | ||||
| A3 | events | 8 / 296 | not stated; randomized; registry:flow |
Nausea (3 lines; O27A)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 76 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 52 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 9 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events |
Vomiting (3 lines; O27B)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 35 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 31 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 5 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events |
Diarrhea (9 lines; O27C)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 44 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A1 | events | 0 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A1 | events | 0 / 295 | not stated; safety; Chronic diarrhea; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 34 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 1 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 1 / 293 | not stated; safety; Chronic diarrhea; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 15 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 0 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 0 / 296 | not stated; safety; Chronic diarrhea; registry:adverse_events |
Constipation (3 lines; O27D)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 12 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 6 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 5 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:adverse_events |
Gallbladder and biliary disease (6 lines; O28)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 1 / 295 | not stated; safety; Cholecystitis acute; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A1 | events | 0 / 295 | not stated; safety; Cholelithiasis; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 0 / 293 | not stated; safety; Cholecystitis acute; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 2 / 293 | not stated; safety; Cholelithiasis; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 1 / 296 | not stated; safety; Cholecystitis acute; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 0 / 296 | not stated; safety; Cholelithiasis; registry:adverse_events |
Acute pancreatitis (3 lines; O29)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 0 / 295 | not stated; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A2 | events | 0 / 293 | not stated; safety; registry:outcomes | ||||
| A3 | events | 0 / 296 | not stated; safety; registry:outcomes |
Intestinal obstruction or ileus (3 lines; O37B)
| Week | Arm | Statistic | Estimate | SE or SD | 95% CI | Events / N | Detail |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A1 | events | 1 / 295 | not stated; safety; Ileus paralytic; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A2 | events | 0 / 293 | not stated; safety; Ileus paralytic; registry:adverse_events | ||||
| A3 | events | 0 / 296 | not stated; safety; Ileus paralytic; registry:adverse_events |